Friday, August 27, 2021

What is "Exhausted?"

I swear this will be the last thing I write, good or bad, about the future of Jeopardy.

I'm not exactly blogging on a daily basis about game shows, but I'm bored with the ongoing saga that is the Jeopardy host search. 

I wrote about names being floated as a potential new host more than two years ago. I was satisfied with the choice of a game show executive and occasional emcee, Mike Richards, being chosen as the new host. Disappointed, I was, but satisfied. 

And then 36 hours after I recorded a podcast, during which I endorsed the choice of Richards, despite some scrutiny of his past, it all went drastically wrong for Richards. And here we are. 

Nobody cares what I think when it comes to who's next, but here I am, nonetheless. 

I no longer care. I'll watch it, or I won't. Either way, it just doesn't matter to me any more. 

I didn't care for the parade of guest hosts on Jeopardy, and I wasn't offended by it. I read way too many articles the past several months about which host was the best, who might be in the running or why a few fans of the show were dying to see LeVar Burton host the game. It was amusing. 

I'm officially bored with the stories, speculation and questionable reporting about what will happen next. 

I grew up watching game shows, in an era where they may have been a dozen being produced on a consistent basis for daytime and syndicated television viewing. I watch game shows for a good game, or a fun game. I don't watch because of who the emcee is. I liked some emcees more than others, but I can't recall ever ignoring a game show because I had no appreciation or respect for the host. 

Today's weird world of televised entertainment has changed all that. So be it. I'm one viewer, nobody needs me. 

Jeopardy is an established game show. It has ascended to some sort of god-like status that I never imagined in 1984. The host is no longer just an emcee. Somehow the host is now a deity. I guess I've been in denial of that. 

All I want is an emcee for the game. Somebody competent and personable. Viewers today must look at the hosts of game shows as entertainers. Too often we see comedians hosting shows, not emcees. You can be both. You can be one, and learn to be the other. But all I want is an emcee. I'm weird. 

I won't boycott Jeopardy if Mayim Bialik is the new, full-time host. And I'm sure she'd love the job if it is offered. 

Allegedly she had been the first choice of the Sony honchos in charge of Jeopardy, but it wasn't going to work with her latest sitcom obligations. I'd wager $2,000 she'd dump that sitcom as fast as possible if it meant she could land the Jeopardy gig outright, rather than the prime time specials and future projects she has been offered thus far. Jeopardy has the potential to be a long-term gig, and it's unlikely any sitcom role she has or will be offered will ever offer the potential of job security the Jeopardy gig promises. 

The renewed search for a new host suggested early on that it was Ken Jennings' job to lose. I think he would have been the first choice previously if it weren't for the fact he's periodically both unfunny and offensive on Twitter. Articles of the past week suggest that's the case.

I've read plenty of handicapping of what Jeopardy might do next, after it airs one week of shows that Richards hosted, and three fill-in weeks featuring Bialik. Some opinions, not surprisingly, lobby for Bialik. Some say Burton should now get the gig. 

Both were OK during their run. I barely sampled Burton's efforts during the week he was a guest host. In both cases, I was reminded I was watching an actor hosting a game show. I don't want to watch an actor host a game show. I want to watch an emcee.

Hire an emcee for the gig. Jennings doesn't fit the mold, but he's not an actor. He's still a better choice than Bialik or Burton. 

When the decision is finally made, and we move on as a country, I'll watch, or I won't. Either way, I am done caring about who the next host is, because I'm not the viewer Jeopardy is worried about. I'm a guy who wants to watch a good game show, and that's not the audience the honchos at Sony are catering to. 

I'll let people know I like, or don't like, the next host, and leave it at that. 

Thursday, August 12, 2021

What is "Disappointed?"

Count me among those are disappointed that Ken Jennings isn't going to be the new host of Jeopardy.

He seemed to be the choice of many game show enthusiasts, based upon the wacky online world I navigate. 

Perhaps the most famous champion in Jeopardy history, Jennings seemed poised to make the improbable leap from contestant to host. He catapulted to a level of celebrity we seldom see by game show contestants. Plenty of people get their 15 minutes thanks to a game show, I can't recall any contestant who has become more of a household name than Jennings, thanks to a game show, in my adult life. 

But today we learned that, indeed, Mike Richards is the new host. (Who?)

Did Jennings lose out on the job because he has been less than perfect on Twitter? How much those insensitive/offensive quips/jokes years ago played into the decision, we'll never know. Or did Sony, the parent company of Jeopardy, choose another Alex Trebek simply because that's the right thing to do? 

Richards, our new host, doesn't have the name recognition of a Bob Barker. But he's not a bad choice, and not entirely surprising. 

The guy has a healthy resume, and it's primarily in game shows. He has at least one "reality" show on his resume, as well, and most of his career has been behind the camera. He has hosted a couple of traditional game shows on the Game Show Network, but he brings no familiarity to most casual game show enthusiasts. I wouldn't be surprised if most Jeopardy viewers had no idea who he was until he took a two-week turn as a guest host, immediately following six weeks of hosting by Jennings. 

While there was speculation that Sony might choose a celebrity to take over the show, I doubted it. Several news anchors/broadcasters took a turn at the podium in the past several months. Once upon a time, game shows looked to such folks as possible hosts for a show. Jeopardy certainly could have offered the gig to a broadcaster, but I didn't think any of the guest hosts they trotted out were likely to leave the gigs they have for the Jeopardy job. 

I didn't expect NFL malcontent Erin Rodgers would get the job, either. He did fine, and he would have loved the gig. He might have even been willing to retire if the job was offered to him on that condition. The guy loves swimming in the celebrity pool when he's not playing football, and having a potential long-term gig as the host of Jeopardy would have ensured his place among the Hollywood glitterati, potentially for decades. 

Rodgers would have brought a few new eyeballs to the show, I suppose, but he might have rubbed a few of the hardcore Jeopardy fans the wrong way. He did just fine as a guest host, and would have been fine as a long-term host, I suspect. But at the end of the day, it seems appropriate that Jeopardy is helmed by somebody who brings an air of authority to the proceedings. 

And Jennings would have done just that. 

Yet they went with Trebek 2.0.

Everybody raves about how effortless, precise and flawless Trebek did the job for nearly four decades. I concur. And he was pretty good at it back in the 1980s, as well. But I doubt many people looked at Trebek as an intellectual elite in 1984. The guy was a Canadian refugee, and a somewhat successful game show host when Jeopardy returned to television with him at the podium. 

I was familiar with Trebek when Jeopardy launched its current run. I was watching game shows, and I had seen him host a couple. He had about 10 years of television experience in the United States, and gigs prior to that in Canada. And his greatest success in the United States was High Rollers, a show that ran for a few years under two separate runs. It was a dice game with general knowledge and trivia questions, far from the mental exercise that Jeopardy runs its contestants through. 

Trebek had hosted a couple of cerebral games prior to Jeopardy, but he didn't bring any great intellectual cachet to the proceedings. He was a solid, well-traveled emcee who turned out to be the right host at the right time. 

Richards has a long resume in the industry, too, and he is a lot like the guy he is replacing. He's a polished, experienced emcee. History has repeated itself. 

Some of the game show experts have chimed in online today. And by experts I'm talking about people like me, who don't work in the industry. The experts think Jeopardy's announcement that Richards will host the daily game, and that actress Mayim Bialik will host previously unannounced prime time specials and a potential spinoff series, is Sony hedging its bets, as if it's concerned that Richards may tank, and the show will suffer. So perhaps Sony is prepping Bialik as a backup plan by having her host prime time specials.

Maybe there's an ounce of concern in Sony's plan, but most of us who watch Jeopardy didn't tune in to see if Trebek was going to make a funny quip during the contestant interviews. We tuned in to watch a competitive game, with substantial money on the line. We'll keep tuning in, and Richards will do just fine.

If anything, Bialik is the lesser of the two talents. She brings a well-established air of authority to the proceedings, and is a successful actress. As a host, I found her style to be slightly distracting during her guest stint. Was it enough that I couldn't watch the show? No, of course not. But she isn't an emcee by nature, and that's what I want when I watch a game show, especially Jeopardy.

And it's atypical these days, but it's not unheard of to have two separate versions of a show airing with separate hosts. Everyone associates The Price is Right with Barker. And for more than three decades he was the host of the daytime show on CBS. But there was a separate nighttime version of the game that ran in three different incarnations. And each one had a separate host. The most successful was the first one, which ran for about eight years during the 1970s. Barker did take over as host of that, but for its first five years or so, a guy named Dennis James was the host at night. 

The long running Pyramid game show had a similar set up in the 1970s. Dick Clark hosted the daytime show, a nighttime version was helmed by Bill Cullen. 

Steve Harvey is hosting both the regular and the celebrity versions of Family Feud, but prior to Harvey, NBC's Al Roker hosted a celebrity edition rather than the daytime host, John O'Hurley, in 2008. 

O'Hurley wasn't exactly an institution during his tenure as the Feud host, and neither is Mike Richards. If Sony is looking to differentiate special prime time Jeopardy episodes, a separate host makes sense to me. (Nobody seemed upset that sportscaster Dan Patrick hosted a few years of Sports Jeopardy, which Trebek probably would have enjoyed and had fun with, given its casual atmosphere.)

Jennings will do just fine without the gig, and I have no reason to believe Jeopardy will go in the tank with Trebek 2.0 at the helm.

I would have made different choices had it been my call. And so would everyone else who watches the show, based on the fan feedback I read during the first 12 hours of the announcement. But it's 1984 all over again, and Jeopardy will be just fine. 

Tuesday, December 1, 2020

Bob Barker reminds us 2020 hasn't been all bad

Here it comes, nonstop Bob Barker!

Much to the surprise of seemingly everyone who adores game shows of the past, Bob Barker is back on TV. 

Well, sort of, but nobody is complaining. 

On Nov. 30 it was announced that Barker episodes of The Price is Right would be available, 24 hours a day, through Pluto TV, the streaming television app that amazes me. 

Pluto TV is like its own cable system, and its channels are available through an app for your phone and your fancy TV. When I found it a few years ago, when streaming video apps were a hot new commodity, I thought it was an interesting concept, albeit a bit clunky. Pluto seemed like a depository for streaming channels that weren't worthy of their own app on your smart TV. The commercial breaks were usually poorly inserted into the programming, and some of the channels featured content akin to watching amateur YouTube videos. 

I've watched Pluto evolve over the years, and am a bit amazed at how it has expanded. Every month Pluto seems to add multiple channels. In some cases the channels are simply duplication of existing outlets available elsewhere, such as home shopping channels and Buzzr, a classic game show channel that is available as a diginet in many cities, including Minneapolis. (Buzzr also streams its channel through its own website.)

Other Pluto channels are dedicated to classic television shows. You can currently watch episodes of Love Boat, Three's Company, One Day at a Time, classic Doctor Who, Wings and The Addams Family, among others, any time day or night. There are also channels that feature a rotation of classic TV shows, and there's an on-demand arm of Pluto for some television shows and movies. 

And I didn't mention then news, sports, cinema or streaming music channels Pluto offers, as this isn't about Pluto. 

With little notice, it was announced Nov. 30 that Pluto was adding 24/7 Bob Barker as of Dec. 1. And for fans of yesteryear and Barker's hosting, it is glorious. 

The show is under the ownership of Fremantle, a television heavyweight that owns the catalogs and intellectual property of multiple production companies of the past. It owns a ton of game shows, including the catalog of Goodson-Todman, the prolific company that was churning out plenty of heavy hitters in the game show biz during the 1970s and '80s, including Match Game and Family Feud. 

In 1994 game show fans were gifted with a cable channel, Game Show Network, that licensed the rights to rerun game shows of the past. I will forgo recounting the roller coaster that is GSN's history, but I will note that in its early years GSN aired classic Barker episodes. But those haven't been on GSN for many years. 

More than five years ago we were blessed with Buzzr, a fake cable channel launched by Fremantle. Using its catalog of classic game shows, the free digital television channel has been running a modest selection of episodes from Fremantle's vast archive. But it has never included The Price is Right, either the Barker era or shows from the past 12 seasons featuring Drew Carey as the host. (Black-and-white ere shows from the 1950s, hosted by Bill Cullen, have shown up on Buzzr occasionally, but it's a very different show than Barker's version.)

I've never read why Buzzr doesn't carry the most valuable game show in Fremantle's catalog, but I have to assume that it has something to do with its existing contract with CBS, which has aired the show since 1972. I'm only guessing. 

So it quite the surprise to learn that Fremantle was making Barker episodes available exclusively through Pluto, 24 hours a day. 

Bob in all his glory

Bob loved chatting with the contestants.

I sampled a few hours of the show on Dec. 1, and it's as entertaining as I remember. (This is not a shock, I have occasionally watched bits and pieces of Barker's catalog through videos posted on YouTube. There's no shortage of partial and full episodes of varying quality available any time you want.)

Pluto launched with season 11 episodes, meaning the 1982-83 season. It is believed that season 11 was chosen because it is the first year the show no longer offered fur coats, something Barker wanted nothing to do with, according to many reports. 

Those early '80s episodes look as dated as you would expect, and they're still a ton of fun. From the sound of Johnny Olson's voice beckoning contestants to "come on down" to the fashions and hairstyles of the models and audience, it's all glorious. 

In the early '80s, people dressed up, at least somewhat, to attend a taping. Shorts, baseball caps and T-shirts proclaiming love for all things TPIR are hard to spot in the audience. I've seen a few people wearing jeans, and I've seen men wearing suits. Anyone wearing a suit to TPIR today would look highly out of place. 

Today's TPIR is rather streamlined, allowing for more commercials within its 60 minutes. Once upon a time, Bob bantered with contestants as they arrived in contestant's row or joined him on stage. If he was getting a good response from the audience, his banter with a contestant may last for a minute. You'd never see that today. 

Watching nearly 40-year-old episodes of the show highlighted details of its evolution that I had forgotten. Some of it is rather trivial. When the models were showing off a new car, they typically held a small sign with the manufacturer's name on it initially. I'm not sure why that was important. 

If it's not on a handheld sign, how is the viewer supposed to understand it's a Chrysler?

Today's TPIR still relies upon groceries and small household products for its pricing games. In the past, those products were plugged by name. Every last one, presumably because they paid a fee to be plugged in a pricing game. Nowadays you'll see a recognizable grocery item, but it often won't be referenced by name. This was not lost upon me, but you don't appreciate how many products were plugged until you watch a vintage episode. 

The pricing games are a bit simpler in design, and a little less flashy, than their modern counterparts, but they're still fun. Occasionally the '80s technology comes up short during an episode, and you will see some of those technical glitches in the show. I think those sorts of things still happen, but with less frequency in 2020. 

Barker played to, and off, the crowd frequently. He'd turn to the audience for a response at some point most every day, it seemed. And he'd be quick to point out when the consensus from the audience was wrong. 

He also ribbed contestants occasionally. During one episode he joked about how he had told them during a commercial break he would kick them in the ankles if they failed to spin the wheel one full revolution during the Showcase Showdown. He continued with this bit by suggesting he'd move to the knees, and then suggested working his way up toward the head. In the early '80s, this was seen as playful and fun. It wasn't mean spirited, but I suspect such proclamations from Drew Carey in 2020 might not be laughed off. 

So far I've seen a few retired games show up in moments I've watched. One was Poker Game, which was in the rotation for more than three decades and was retired in 2007. It was mostly a guessing game, but I found it entertaining. 

Make a better hand for yourself than you do for the house, and you win a prize!

Another game that showed up in 1982 was Trader Bob, a game that ran for about five years in the early '80s. The game simulates a trading post, but isn't that exciting. It basically requires players to pick the more expensive item from three pairs of small prizes in order to win a bedroom set or dining room group. 

It's Optional was another game that had a five-year run, starting in 1978. It wasn't used frequently, according to online reports, and that's probably because the contestant was playing for two new cars. The episode I saw featured two Ford Escorts. The premise of the game is to guess which options to add to the price of a stripped down car so that the price of the car is comparable to that of a fancier car, without going over. I'm guessing in most instances a contestant had to pick out about $1,000 worth of options to equalize the price of the two vehicles, with a $100 margin or error. 

It's Optional was a reminder that air conditioning wasn't standard in cars way back when. Some of the other options you could choose for your stripped down vehicle were tinted glass, cloth bucket seats, color floor mats and automatic transmission. 

It was an odd game, and I'm not surprised it disappeared more than 35 years ago. 

Pick your automotive options, and if they add up to a magic number, you win two new cars!

The Price is Right used fancy split-screen technology during It's Optional.

When I saw Pick-A-Pair, it brought back a vague memory of the game from my youth. The game debuted in 1982, but has had a different presentation for many years. The game is simple, there are six grocery items comprised of three sets of equally-priced products. The contestant has two chances to find a matching pair of items. 

Since 1988, all six products are on display on a long, flat tabletop, speeding up the game play, no doubt. In its early years, the products rotated into view on a miniature Ferris wheel, making it impossible for the contestant to see all six grocery items at the same time. 

Pick-A-Pair was colorful and slow in its early years.

The showcases bring back fond memories. Plenty of showcases weren't that spectacular in the '80s, as three was no car or truck, boat or fabulous trip to be won. But plenty of showcases offer one of those coveted prizes. 

The showcase nostalgia comes from the fact that the show used skits periodically. There's be a short story that linked the showcase prizes, and sometimes the story included props, an elaborate set or pencil sketches to accent the story. The presentation wasn't highly technical, so the props and special effects were akin to a high school theater production.  

Olson, the announcer, would sometimes appear in the skits, and costumes for some or all of the models were frequently part of the presentation. In one showcase, a model was dressed up as an organ grinder's monkey. In another, a model was dressed up as an alien.

What better way to introduce the prizes in a showcase than emulating an auction?

Illustrations about types of clubs set up the showcase prize presentation during a showcase.

There were simple showcase themes in the '80s that were abandoned long ago. One recurring showcase was a trip down Main Street. Two doors open in a dark studio, and each door has two prizes behind it. The idea was that the prizes represented a look into the storefront windows of a bustling downtown district. 

The showcases weren't mind blowing or fall-off-the-couch hilarious, but they represent a bygone era of the show, and offer nostalgic fun. Much to my surprise, one of the showcases I saw today used the Star Wars theme as its background music. From a licensing standpoint I would have assumed that episode would have remained in moth balls. 

For those that have had a love of games shows throughout their life, seeing Bob work his magic on a periodic basis is a welcome, and unexpected, opportunity. 

Fun fact: Bob celebrates his 97th birthday next week. 

Temptation, played for a car, has been in the show's pricing game rotation since 1973.

Shell Game has been around since 1974. 

A 1982 showcase features a Pac-Man arcade cabinet. I was a bit obsessed with that game and the idea of winning one on The Price is Right would have blown my mind. 


Sunday, July 12, 2020

I don't care what the survey says, Family Feud is still a boring show

I was reminded today that it's the 44th anniversary of Family Feud's premiere.

July 12, 1976, barely a week after our country celebrated its bicentennial, a fresh, new and exciting game show hit the daytime airwaves, back in the glory days of ABC, when morning chat fests weren't all the rage.

I'm still amazed. A show that I find to be a bit boring and slow has been on TV for most of the past 44 years.

Any game show historian can recite all sorts of trivia about the show. They can explain how the show is based upon the bonus game of TV's Match Game, how other hosts were considered and why Richard Dawson, a regular panelist on Match Game since its revamped debut in 1973, got the job.

I have watched the show in every incarnation, and I find it less appealing than ever.

As a kid who enjoyed game shows, it had its appeal. Generally I find that shows with a play-along factor are more fun to watch. I might not have been worldly as a kid, but I could play along with some of the questions. They were survey questions, not general knowledge trivia questions, so there were multiple answers, and wrong answers were those that simply didn't make the survey. I think the fact that you didn't have to be Jeopardy smart to play along was one factor that made it a success.

Richard Dawson (photo via laist.com)
Unquestionably, the show's success was due in large part to Dawson as host. He was quick-witted, charming and the show allowed him a little time to interact with members of a family, or spend a minute pontificating at the start of a show. The way 30-minute TV games shows are produced these days, he wouldn't have been afforded such luxury.

Thanks to cable television and digi-nets, we've had chances to review Dawson's work during the past 25 or so years. I get why the show worked back in the day, but I find it rather slow and dull at this point in my life. The bonus round was entertaining, but you had to sit through rounds of mundane questions to get to it.

The show was successful enough to earn a nighttime edition, in addition to the weekday morning slot over most of these ABC stations. And it inspired occasional celebrity editions, which ABC dropped into its prime time schedule. It had a nice run of about nine years.

It didn't take more than a few years before the show returned in the late 1980s for another several years. Most of that time it was helmed by Ray Combs. The show looked and played largely the same, although there was a tweak to it eventually. Under Combs, the host's banter had a bit more playful and mischievous of a tone, but it seemed to do well. I watched it now and again.

Combs was relieved of his duties after six years or so, and Dawson was brought back in an attempt to rejuvenate the show, nearly a decade after he had signed off as its host. That lasted a year. The show was dead again.

Approximately four years later, Feud was back again, circa 1999, with Minnesota-born comedian Louie Anderson as the host. The look and theme of the show were different, but for the most part it was that familiar show we all knew. If you would have told me in 1999 that the show would air uninterrupted for more than two decades, I'd have bet $100 you were wrong.

The show switched hosts after a few years, with Home Improvement's Richard Karn taking over for four years. Then came Seinfeld's John O'Hurley for four years. Each guy had his own style and personality, but none of them dazzled me. I can't speak to how the ratings were, but they were good enough to bring the show back for yet another year.

Then in 2010 Feud brought in Steve Harvey, and the show has done rather well for years.

I don't get the appeal, but it doesn't matter. Feud is doing quite well without me.

I get why it's successful, to a point. As my buddy and I say, we live in a Jerry Springer society. The show went from asking mundane questions, such as "Name something you need for a day at the beach?" to "Name an organ that only an idiot would donate while he's still alive?" People are going to say "his penis," and it makes the survey.

When a contestant answers "penis," Steve Harvey does a little routine, because that's what the audience wants, and the producers post a euphemism on the board, to the roar of the crowd. It might be "his ding-a-ling," or it might be "his baloney pony." The crowd will go wild, America has been entertained.

For some, Feud is fun. The old reruns offer nostalgic charm, or the new episodes offer "outrageous" answers that are hilarious. The game is a pretty good one, and timeless. Questions can be updated to reflect the times. Questions can be written with a specific audience in mind. After more than four decades, it's still making money for a lot of people.

For me, it has had its moments. Today, the nostalgic charm of Dawson is only good in small doses. Since I don't watch Family Feud to see a comedian do his act while hosting the show, Harvey does nothing for me. And I don't find his shtick to be that funny. But again, he doesn't need me.

Faster isn't always better, but after four decades I can say that Feud has given me something that is entertaining, and worth more than 30 minutes of my time in any given week, although I don't get a chance to watch it very often. The Game Show Network has a show called America Says, which is basically Feud against the clock. It's a more entertaining game than Feud, and it only took four decades of Feud success for somebody to come up with a knock off version I enjoy.

Perhaps I'll be reminiscing about America Says in four decades. I'd be happy with that.

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

"Premiere" night for Press Your Luck and Card Sharks

Despite the fact it was the second showing of Press Your Luck, ABC insists the second episode this week is the premiere. OK, if you say so.

I like the new format. Since this show does not have returning champions, I like the fact there's something else to play for if you win the game. It's prime time, so you need to raise the stakes, it seems. The bonus game does that.

As for the Wednesday night, June 12, episode: It was a fun game with a classic duel at the end to determine the champion. The winner went to the bonus round, where the level of drama wasn't as high as the first show. It was fun to watch. I like the show.

One side observation about the contestants, and seemingly every contestant on prime time games. Why are the contestants told to wave their arms, bounce around, dance and/or gyrate? I get that some people are excited. Some people can't contain their enthusiasm. But when every contestant seems to be playing to the camera, it feels so artificial. Again, I'm sure I'm the only person who is bothered by it.

As for the early reviews of PYL, many of which I read via threads on Facebook, as I don't belong to a game show forum: The reviews of Banks as host are mixed. Some people claimed she was great. Some said they didn't like her. Nobody explained why they felt that way.

As for the new bonus game, some folks think it is too long and is too drawn out. Some people want two 30-minute games packaged into an hour of TV. One person suggested that the bonus game could be the basis for the show. 

Other comments: The game play in the bonus game is akin to Deal or No Deal. You're trying to cash out at the best time, beating the house. But there's no competition in the bonus game.

Not many people professed a love of the bonus game, but several think it's too much. I'm not sure if they're going to boycott the show because of it, but my suggestion, if you find the bonus game to be an agonizing waste of your time, is to watch the main game and turn off the TV when there's a winner. Your problem is solved, and your life is better for it.

One petty gripe: Drop the claim that PYL is "television's most competitive game." I'm not sure why that was brilliant back in the 1980s, but it's lame, and it's lame today.

I watched the debut of the new Card Sharks, as well, on Wednesday. It's OK.

I have few complaints. I didn't think host Joel McHale was outstanding, but he didn't oversell his comedy routine while hosting, which I assumed he would do. He didn't yell like a high school cheerleader, which I greatly appreciated. My only criticism of his hosting is that he seemed a bit sedated. I don't need him to yell and dance, a la Banks, but I didn't sense he was punctuating the high points of the game all that well.

Ultimately, of all the hosts of ABC's six prime time game shows, he's the best. Easily.

As for the game play, having the contestants play one mega-game for a chance at the "money cards," which I don't think they referred to the bonus game as, is a bit slow and tedious. The format is otherwise familiar: Contestants answer survey questions, mostly, and whomever is correct controls the board and earns the perks that go with that. I expected "naughty" questions, because that's what today's viewers want, allegedly. But the questions avoided sexually suggestive content, and that was nice to see.

The show's game play is clunky. When the "models" have to "change that card," they look awkward concealing the new card until they're ready to turn it over at the game board. It's a minor quibble, but the card flow is awkward.

The bonus game is rather close to the late 1970s/early 1980s version of the "money cards," but with minor changes I won't detail here. For some silly reason the players use giant poker chips to represent their bets. That's unnecessary, and silly.

Since the winner of the main game wins $10,000, he or she starts the bonus game with $10,000 in chips. If I did the math right, you could earn a maximum of $1.28 million in the bonus game. It will be interesting to see if anyone cashes for more more than $500,000 in the bonus game. With good luck and a little risk tolerance, I could see it happening.

It's unclear if the champion goes home with $10,000 even if he or she busts out during the bonus game. One contestant did that during the premiere.

Like other ABC prime time games, the show is ready made for splitting into independent, half-hour episodes.

I don't find the basic format of Card Sharks all that entertaining. Yeah, I can play along with the contestants during the survey questions they answer, and decide how I'd call the next card on their board, but that has never captivated me. I'll certainly watch McHale's Card Sharks again. It's unlikely I'll see an episode of Pyramid this summer. And there's no chance I'll be watching Celebrity Family Feud. The only reason I'd sit through an hour of Match Game, which I haven't enjoyed since its return, is if there's a fringe celebrity that I really want to see. And there are few of those.

Speaking of Match Game, I watched the first half of Wednesday night's episode, and that was enough. The humor is lacking, the questions aren't clever, or funny and the celebrities aren't very entertaining. I can't say that the show lacks star power, I'm no authority on today's crop of celebrities, but I didn't even know a thing about three, and perhaps four, of the six celebrity panelists. Of the two I knew, only one was truly noteworthy, and that was Jason Alexander. And he hasn't exactly been dazzling the masses in the 20 years since Seinfeld went off the air. Yep, his claim to fame has been wrapped up for two decades. But I gotta hand it to him, he doesn't look like he has aged much.

Tuesday, June 11, 2019

The new Press Your Luck: As good as I could have hoped for

As a youngster growing up in the Minneapolis area, I was a huge fan of Press Your Luck, despite the fact it was never broadcast in my TV market.

Our local CBS affiliate never aired the show. Sure, The Price is Right, was a fixture at 10 a.m., but somehow the local station had something more important to air at other hours of the morning.

Yet I was a huge fan of PYL, as I would watch it every chance I had while spending holiday breaks or parts of my summer vacation at my dad's house in Wisconsin. Having divorced parents wasn't all bad.

While I've rarely had access to cable TV's Game Show Network, I've had opportunities to watch reruns of the game throughout my life. Like other fans of the show, who have watched it take on a second life via Facebook games, casino slot machines and other interactive platforms, I've hoped the day would come when the excitement of the game show could be produced for a new generation. Yes, there was a new version produced by the Game Show Network more than a decade ago, and the tweaks to the format weren't all bad. But overall it didn't entertain me like the CBS daytime predecessor more than 15 years earlier. (Dang, it has been more than 15 years since the GSN version of PYL was produced. Time flies.)

ABC has been banking on game shows to fill hours of its summer schedule the past couple of years, with marginal success. I have yet to find one I enjoy and make a point of watching. As much as I have loved the 1970s era of Match Game, ABC's Alec Baldwin version just doesn't entertain me enough, despite the fact it remains rather faithful to the 1970s version.

So I had reservations about the new Press Your Luck. I was expecting that it would remain faithful to the 1980s version, (which was the second attempt at turning the game into a hit game show,) but I had my doubts I would enjoy it.

For the most part, I like it, and it's the first ABC game show that I will make a point of watching on a regular basis.

What I like: With one minor tweak, the main game is played the same as the original show.

The question-and-answer rounds that award spins aren't the most fascinating segments, as there's usually at least one gimme question to ensure every player earns at least one spin. But those two rounds are short segments of the game.

The game board has plenty of modern prizes, and more money available than 35 years ago, which you would expect. And it's prime time, you've got to offer more tempting prizes if you want people to watch. Good games are fun to watch, regardless of the prizes, but it's harder to get casual viewers to watch and dream of winning big if there's little on the line. As I have said before, Deal or No Deal fails completely as a game show if the top prize is $10,000.

I like that there is at least one huge prize on the board during round 2. Having a top cash square of $10,000 is twice what the old show offered, and seems appropriate. Having a prize worth nearly four times that amount -- a Jaguar during the debut episode -- on the board certainly makes the game more exciting.

And the new twist to the prime time show, a bonus round, is pretty well done. It has its flaws, but I like it. I'll dissect it in a moment.

Cosmetically, the show is well done. I don't need to see the audience, but the audience is visible in shots throughout the game. I didn't expect the show to recreate the 1980s technology of the original, but the style and sound effects were updates of the original show. There's comfort in familiarity.

Finally, when it comes to the Whammy, the animated character(s) that steal(s) your winnings when you land on it instead of cash or a prize, I have no complaints. The animation wasn't slick, and it mirrors the look and feel of the '80s era. The animations are contemporary, for the most part, but they've recreated a  few of the classic Whammy animations, reportedly, and we saw one during the premiere episode.

What I dislike: I don't dislike Elizabeth Banks, but I will always prefer an emcee over an actor as the host of my game shows. 

I'm not familiar with her work. I know her name, but I couldn't tell you five things about her career. I've never seen her work in the Hunger Games or Pitch Perfect film franchises. And I never will. I've seen her in small roles in a few movies, most notably as Betty Brandt in the original Spider-Man trilogy, which I know only because I scanned her Wikipedia page. She has done little in the realm of non-scripted film and television work, as best I can tell. I have no idea why she was picked to host a prime time game show, but it struck me as an odd choice from the start.

I'm no TV insider, but I have sensed that there was an ounce of pressure on ABC to choose a woman as host one of their new shows this year. Fine with me. I am not fascinated by the aura of Meredith Vieira, but she did just fine for more than a decade as host of the syndicated version of Who Wants to Be a Millionaire. She's allegedly returning to syndicated TV this fall with another game show, last I knew.

So man or woman, I don't care who hosts the new PYL. But I'd rather have a traditional emcee. Banks is very good in some ways, a little too Oprah for me in other ways.

At times during her hosting, Banks would whoop it up when a contestant hit a big prize, as if she were Oprah, giving away cars to her studio audience. (Her little dance routine prior to the start of a prize round was awkward.) Her cheerleading won't lead to the end of the world, but I'd rather have a host that punctuates the excitement than a host that cheers along with the audience.

I'm glad that Banks isn't cut from the same cloth of so many game show hosts of the past two decades: A known comedian who is looking for a gig to help keep his or her name in the public conscience. Those comedians are often expected to drop their little jokes into the show, it seems, which annoys me. I'm in the minority on this, but I don't care for it. Levity is fine, doing your act, a la Steve Harvey on Family Feud, ain't why I'm watching the game. And when your shtick isn't particularly funny, you've ruined the show for me. Again, I'm in the minority.

Banks isn't Chelsea Handler, thankfully, but she did drop a few quips and jokes into the show. It ain't the end of the world, but it doesn't entertain me, especially when those quips feel scripted and set up. Perhaps she's naturally that clever, but it didn't come off that way.

Her quips and commentary aren't unlike classic PYL host Peter Tomarken. But Tomarken's routine seemed natural. Banks' comments seem forced, and only distract from the game play.

Overall she did a good job of explaining the game and directing traffic. She was surprisingly comfortable during the first episode. I'm not a fan of her style, but I'd take her over Baldwin and Harvey, for sure. Banks might have been perfect for Match Game, actually.

The other complaint I have about the show is that when it gets to the bonus game, the producers seem to think they need to manufacture drama, much like Deal or No Deal or The Wall on NBC. Ish. More on that in a moment.

The bonus game: I wasn't sure what a PYL bonus game would look like. And I was quite surprised by what we got.

When you watch Match Game and $100,000 Pyramid on ABC, you can tell that they're carefully produced and edited so that they could easily be repackaged as two independent 30-minute episodes for future syndication and rerunning. I'm not sure about how they produce Celebrity Family Feud, I won't watch it.

I expected Press Your Luck to be similarly produced -- two games played in an hour, with a simple bonus game crammed into the end of each main game. Instead we get the winner of the main game playing a solo game, under different rules, for a chance at big money. I didn't see that coming.

I like the way they structured the bonus game. You play multiple rounds with the prize values increasing during each round. You have to play every spin given to you at the start of each round, but you can quit when you complete each round if you don't want to risk losing your earnings in the subsequent round. And like always, four Whammys ends your game.

Also fun, they include prizes that are personalized to the player. If it were me, for example, one of the prizes on the board might be a limited edition pinball machine worth $10,000. It's a nice touch.

If I followed the explanation, the value of the "big bucks" goes up each round, starting at $10,000 in the first round, and finishing at $100,000 during the fifth, and final, round. And if you manage to bank $500,000 or more in cash and prizes at any point in the bonus game, you automatically win $1 million. How that $1 million is paid out isn't clear. I assume that $1 million includes the value of prizes already in your bank. But it doesn't matter. I don't foresee anyone winning $1 million on this show, but in contrast to ABC's other prime time games, there's potential for bigger winners than you'll get on Match Game or Pyramid. (Word is that Card Sharks will also have a chance at huge money. I'm guessing it'll be as unlikely on that show, too.)

Nobody is likely going to win $1 million on PYL because it's not an all-or-nothing proposition. With multiple rounds and a chance to stop the game at the conclusion of every round, most contestants aren't likely to risk $250,000 in prizes, if they get that far, on another round of game play. Yes, the cash and prizes are bigger in the later rounds, but one Whammy wipes out all that good fortune you've had in banking $250,000. I just don't expect many people to risk that kind of money

So it's a fun twist, and they dedicate half the show to it. That's fine. As you'd expect, there are commercial breaks during the bonus game, but it's as much fun to watch as the main game, despite the lack of competition between players.

The bonus game does have the potential for early disaster. If the player hits four Whammys quickly, the round will be over within a few minutes, and the show will have to tap dance to fill the remainder of the hour, or edit in more banter between Banks and the contestants in the main game.

A player could also stop after the first round, but that's unrealistic. Even a good run in round 1 isn't likely to net the player $50,000 in cash and prizes. And with bigger prizes forthcoming and Whammys to spare, risking $50,000 isn't that big of a risk, as it could easily be built back up with bigger prizes on the board.

So it all sounds like a fun, multi-layered bonus game, right? The big albatross of the bonus game is the manufactured drama.

In the debut episode, the main game winner, Stevey, (who doesn't have a last name, evidently,) was playing for big bucks in the bonus game. As we learned, he's married, and he and his husband have a newborn infant. During the bonus game, Stevey's husband is sitting on a bench off to the side, shown regularly during the bonus game. The husband dabs tears from his eyes more than a few times. After Stevey banks an SUV in a late round -- a prize added that round especially for Stevey, because his husband had to give up his dream vehicle in order for them to have a child via surrogate -- the husband joins Stevey at the podium for a consultation and hug at the end of the round. It's a teary, dramatic moment that people must love, because they do it on shows like Deal or no Deal and The Wall. I'm not people. I don't enjoy it. I don't mind emotion after a win, but when the drama is manufactured and exploited, you haven't improved your game show. You've cheapened it. And that's what America wants, I guess.

In conclusion: Overall it's a good effort at updating the game and ratcheting up the stakes. It's not perfect, and probably never will be unless I'm producing it. But I'm happy with the end product. It's easily my favorite of the ABC prime time games, and I look forward to watching it again.

UPDATE: Additional observations about the show, following night two, as well as a review of Card Sharks, is available in my following night's blog entry.







Friday, April 12, 2019

And the next host of Jeopardy! should be?

All of us who follow game shows, and plenty of people who don't, learned last month that Jeopardy! host Alex Trebek has pancreatic cancer. It's beatable, but the general consensus is that the odds are against him.

There are rumors that Sony, which produces Jeopardy!, is already considering possible replacements. Nobody wants to see Trebek replaced any time soon, but Sony is preparing for the unfortunate scenario that Trebek might not be returning to the helm. Several suggestions for the next host have been discussed wherever game show nerds congregate online. Some I like better than the others. Here's a list of potential hosts, and my response to them.

Jeff Probst: Game show fans suggest the host of TV's Survivor because he hosted Rock & Roll Jeopardy! from 1998 through 2001 on VH1. I never saw much of the show back in the day, but Probst was a rather straight forward host. He could handle Jeopardy with aplomb, but the guy irritates me, and I'd rather not be reminded of that when I watch the show.

I'm jealous of Probst, I'll be the first to admit it. He gets paid decent money for his idiotic hosting gig on Survivor. I've never been a fan of the show, but when I stop to watch 10 minutes of it now and then, listing to him do play-by-play during some goofy competition between the competing teams is painful. The guy has a great gig for which he clearly sold his soul to the devil. I don't want to be reminded of how annoying and silly his career has been by hearing him read questions about Shakespeare on weekday afternoons.

While the new host need not be a guy who will hold the job for 35 years, Probst is 57. Perhaps they should skew younger.

Chris Harrison: Nobody is suggesting this clown, but if you're going to consider Probst, I say consider Harrison, too.

Harrison is as worthless as Probst when it comes to The Bachelor franchise on ABC. I've watched The Bachelor for a few years, mostly because my buddy can't resist it, and it makes for great fodder when we talk. It's so stupid sometimes, I feel dirty for watching it, and can't believe my buddy has been tuning in for years. Harrison only adds to the stupidity. But again, it's a great gig. It's pointless, and it beats working for a living, although I have to believe the guy is basically a puppet.

For the past couple of years he's been holding a second job, hosting Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? He's decent at that, despite how annoying he is on The Bachelor. It's widely assumed that Millionaire is about to have its plug pulled. If so, Harrison could use a new second gig, and he's 47. He's got a few more years ahead of him than Probst, presumably.

I'm not rooting for either guy to garner any consideration, but I'd take Bachelor guy over Survivor guy.

Meredith Vieira: The first host of syndicated Millionare was suggested by somebody. She held that gig for more than a decade, and did fine. As for Jeopardy!, it ain't happening.

She has a new game show in the works for this fall called 25 Words or Less. So she's booked. She'd be fine as Jeopardy's host, but I'm an ageist, evidently. I seem to want the show to skew young in its hire. Meredith is 65 and quite capable, but let's look elsewhere.

Ken Jennings: There have been suggestions that the king of Jeopardy! take over as host. I like the idea. He's been on TV enough that he's comfortable in front of the camera. He's well known, thanks to the fact Jeopardy! trots him out every chance it gets for some new tournament. And at 44, he's about the age that Trebek was when he started hosting the revival. I like it. I'm no authority, but I gotta believe we've never had a popular game show contestant ascend to host of the show. It's unorthodox, but I have no problem with it.

If you really want to have fun with Jennings as the host, have him play along with Final Jeopardy! during each episode before learning who the day's champion is. A new twist for the show without changing the game play. I'll take it.

Brad Rutter: Jennings received plenty of mainstream media attention for his 74-game run on Jeopardy!, but Rutter is actually the king. Rutter's reign predated Jennings, when champs had to retire after winning five games. In all the super tournaments Jeopardy! has held in the years since Jennings dazzled the nation, Rutter has won every time, defeating Jennings in the process.

Rutter doesn't have the household cachet of Jennings, but he's just as smooth, is just as smart and is trying to carve out a career as an actor or host at this point, so he's more than ready to ascend to the Jeopardy! throne. He's 41, so he has a lot of years ahead of him, and Jeopardy! is running out of excuses to trot him out for special events. He could likewise play along with Final Jeopardy each day.

Anderson Cooper: In the past, Cooper has been suggested as a possible host, and he brings the air of authority you seek in a Jeopardy! host. I'd have no problem with it, but there is a faction that is rubbed the wrong way by the 51-year-old because he's a liberal pawn of CNN. I don't know how many people would boycott Jeopardy! if Cooper hosted it, but I have a feeling a few people would make a stink about him. Enough to keep him from getting the gig? Seems unlikely, but never underestimate a studio making the safe choice.

Tom Bergeron: Did somebody throw out his name somewhere? I think so. The former host of Hollywood Squares is a career emcee, and he hosts light fare, mostly. Despite the fact his paychecks since Hollywood Squares have been the C-list celebrity dance-a-thon and the funny video show, both on ABC, Bergeron would slide nicely onto the Sony set. But he's 63, so that might work against him.

Ricki Lake: Somebody suggested the part-time actress because she did a mediocre job of hosting a summer game show homage years ago. I'm sure she could do it, and I'm sure she'd dazzle nobody in the process.

Those are the names that come to mind. Of all of them, I'm inclined to choose Rutter if it's up to me. I like the idea of him or Jennings, and I think Rutter would be the better choice of the two.

There are suggestions that the new host should be a minority or female because we've had too many white guys historically, I guess. I don't care if the host is male or female, or what ethnic background the host possesses. Hire the best person, not a minority because it seems like the progressive thing to do.

Trebek had an established career in game shows when his Jeopardy! career began. He had hosted shows that skewed toward the intellectual, and shows that were less serious, and had elements of luck woven into the game play. Jeopardy's next host, whenever the day comes, need not be a brainiac who is considered the smartest person in the room. But Trebek lends an air of authority to the proceedings, and I have to think the next host will bring a similar tone to the job.